By Pat Anson
If you’ve heard about kratom and wondered if the herbal supplement might be useful in treating chronic pain, you’ve probably been struck by the wide range of opinions about it.
“Kratom should not be used to treat medical conditions, nor should it be used as an alternative to prescription opioids. There is no evidence to indicate that kratom is safe or effective for any medical use,” said former FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb.
“Kratom has truly not only saved my life but also given me renewed hope. Without this plant I do not believe I would still be alive today,” said kratom user Kim DeMott.
“The drug looks similar to brown powdered kratom, produces similar effects as heroin, and is primarily used… by people addicted to heroin,” reports the Ohio Substance Abuse Monitoring Network.
“Kratom does not make me high, nor do I experience side effects. I am now clear minded without the sedation caused by narcotics,” said Mary Ann Dunkel, one of the estimated two million Americans who use kratom, despite warnings that it is an “emerging public health threat.”
If you’re confused by these diametrically opposed views, you’re not alone. Which is why Steve Hamm produced and directed a new 80-minute documentary called “The Mysteries of Kratom.”
Hamm knew little about kratom until he started chatting with a neighbor, Dr. Marek Chawarski, a Professor of Psychiatry and Emergency Medicine at Yale School of Medicine. Chawarski spent years studying kratom in Southeast Asia, where it has been used for centuries as a natural stimulant and pain reliever.
“When Marek started talking about kratom and just the potential of it being used as an analgesic, as a painkiller, and potentially being used in dealing with opioid addiction. I got really interested,” Hamm explained. “Ultimately, we decided to make this film by asking a core question. Could a leaf of a tree in Southeast Asia help us solve this terrible addiction problem that we have in the US?”
The resulting documentary by Elm City Films is mostly self-funded and takes an even-handed, journalistic approach to the subject. You’ll hear from a grieving mother who believes her son overdosed on kratom, and a pain patient who says kratom is safer and more effective than opioids.
Hamm spent a month with Chawarski in Southeast Asia, learning how kratom is grown, cultivated and used. People there prefer using fresh kratom, either by chewing the leaves or using them to make a tea. Reports of kratom abuse or addiction are rare.
“I have not seen, nor have I heard, of any fatal overdoses from kratom in Malaysia. Non-fatal, there could be possibilities of it, but again there is no documented evidence,” said Vicknasingan Kasinather, a Malaysian professor and kratom researcher
Due to growing demand in the United States, kratom has become an important cash crop in Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia. Most of it is dried and processed before being exported, and that processing could be where some contaminants and chemicals are first introduced.
Once it is shipped overseas, some kratom vendors take the powder and create potent synthetic extracts using an alkaloid called 7-mitragynine, which was recently implicated by the FDA in at least one fatal overdose.
“I was recently at a trade show, where a lot of kratom products are being displayed, and I see these vendors now developing novel new products, including vape pens with 7-mitragynine that by nature are dangerous. They also have 7-mitragynine extracted powders,” said Mac Haddow, a lobbyist for the American Kratom Association. “Those should be banned from the marketplace because they are not natural, they’re synthetically derived, and that’s a real threat to the public.”
Kratom products, like other dietary supplements, are only loosely regulated by the FDA. Many kratom advocates say more regulation is needed, with testing and labeling a better alternative than an outright ban on kratom, which the FDA and DEA tried unsuccessfully to impose in 2016.
“I think the more laws there are about labeling kratom products, the better. Because then there’s more information that gets out there to the consumer,” says Brian Gallagher, a kratom podcaster. “If it was banned everywhere, then you’d go from a grey market to a black market, where there’s no regulation. We have maybe half the companies doing the right thing. When kratom is banned, zero companies will be doing the right thing.”
Hamm hopes his documentary will help people come to a better understanding of kratom’s risks and benefits, and how a simple leaf could be a solution to some of our biggest health problems.
“We look at the science, we look at the people, we look at the legal issues and the controversies that are there. We hope you all enjoy the film, and we hope it will spark a new conversation about kratom, but also about opioids,” he said..